Pioneering the Ethical Elephant Safari in Nepal with Tiger Tops
In May 1962, Jim Edwards arrived in Nepal by accident. The Swedish entrepreneur had set out from Stockholm in an overland drive toward Melbourne, Australia, intending to promote Saab vehicles. After traversing Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East, he reached Delhi where he met Prince Basundhara, the brother of Nepal's king. An invitation to the kingdom was extended. What began as a detour became a life's calling.
Edwards fell in love with Nepal's wild landscapes during hunting and fishing expeditions with the prince. Rather than continue onward, he decided to stay. In 1964, he met Charles McDougal, an American anthropologist turned wildlife ecologist, and together they launched Nepal Wildlife Adventure, offering hunting and fishing expeditions to visitors seeking an authentic jungle encounter.
By 1971, Edwards and McDougal had acquired Tiger Tops Jungle Lodge, a struggling hunting camp operating in Nepal's southern jungles. They made a decisive choice: cease all hunting operations and transform the lodge into a model for conservation tourism. That pivot — from extraction to preservation — set the foundation for what Tiger Tops would become over the next five decades.
The Evolution of Ethical Animal Tourism
Tiger Tops did not emerge from a conservation movement already in motion. Rather, it preceded one. The lodge's shift toward wildlife tourism that prioritized animal welfare and environmental protection was pioneering for its time, especially in a region where tourism infrastructure was still nascent and conservation ethics were not yet codified into industry practice.
Over five decades, Nepal's tourism landscape has evolved dramatically. Wildlife tourism operations have proliferated across the country. The Nepalese government has instituted protections through national park systems and community-run buffer zones that engage local populations in conservation efforts. Yet this growth has revealed a paradox: alongside genuine conservation initiatives exist operations with minimal regard for animal welfare or environmental impact.
The disparity in standards remains significant. While some operators have invested in ethical frameworks and animal welfare protocols, others have not. Regulation from governmental bodies, tourism associations, and the private sector has struggled to keep pace with the expansion of wildlife tourism operations. The result is a landscape where the quality of animal tourism experiences — and their actual conservation impact — depends heavily on individual lodge philosophy and management.
The Elephant Safari: What Sets It Apart
Tiger Tops offers two distinct animal encounter experiences. The first involves traditional wildlife viewing at lodges positioned within both Chitwan and Bardia National Parks, where guests observe animals in their unmanaged natural habitat. The second is the immersive elephant safari, offered exclusively at Tiger Tops's Tharu Lodge.
The distinction matters. Most elephant sanctuaries and tourism operations across Asia lack the ability to move their domestic herds into natural environments. These facilities typically hold elephants in managed grounds. Tiger Tops's approach inverts this model: guests immerse themselves in the daily routines of a domestic elephant herd within Chitwan National Park, observing animals as they would naturally behave, but from proximity that would otherwise be impossible.
This experience is only possible because of institutional knowledge and operational infrastructure that cannot be quickly replicated. Tiger Tops employs naturalists whose combined experience exceeds 50 years working in Nepal's jungles. This depth of knowledge — where to find specific animals, how to interpret behavior, how to move through the landscape without disrupting it — translates directly into the quality and authenticity of guest encounters. Guests do not observe a performance; they observe genuine animal behavior interpreted by experts.
The ethical dimension is embedded in the experience itself. Because the encounters are designed around animal welfare and habitat authenticity, rather than around maximizing guest comfort or photo opportunities, the experience feels fundamentally different. Guests leave with a deeper understanding of the animals they encountered, not merely a collection of images.
Conservation in Practice
Tiger Tops operates across multiple conservation fronts simultaneously. The lodge participates in habitat protection within the national park system. It maintains relationships with local communities whose cooperation is essential for large-scale conservation; when local populations benefit economically from wildlife protection, poaching decreases and habitat recovery becomes possible. The lodge also invests directly in animal welfare, ensuring that its domestic elephant herd receives veterinary care, appropriate nutrition, and humane treatment.
This multi-layered approach illustrates a fundamental principle of modern conservation: tourism can serve as a funding mechanism for protection efforts that might otherwise lack resources. When a lodge generates revenue through ethical animal encounters, that revenue can flow back into habitat management, anti-poaching patrols, veterinary services, and community compensation programs. The economics of conservation tourism, when structured correctly, align profit motive with conservation outcome.
Yet this alignment is not automatic. It requires intentional design and consistent commitment. Many tourism operations extract value from wildlife without returning it to conservation. Tiger Tops's five-decade commitment to reinvestment in the ecosystem distinguishes it in a crowded field.
The Animal Welfare Question
Animal welfare in the context of tourism remains poorly understood and inadequately regulated in Nepal. While international animal welfare standards have become more rigorous in recent years, enforcement and adoption within Nepal's tourism sector remains inconsistent. Some operations have begun investing in improved practices; many have not.
The question facing elephant tourism specifically is whether the practice can ever be ethical. Elephants are highly intelligent, social animals with complex psychological needs. Domestic elephants used in tourism must be trained, which historically has involved coercive methods. Even with modern welfare improvements, questions remain about whether captive use in tourism, however humanely managed, can be reconciled with animal welfare principles.
Tiger Tops's approach attempts to address these concerns by prioritizing naturalistic behavior and minimizing artificial constraints on the animals' daily experience. Yet the fundamental tension persists.
This is not unique to Tiger Tops; it is inherent to any elephant tourism operation. Honest engagement with this tension — rather than dismissal of it — marks a more mature approach to the ethics of animal tourism.
Nepal's Potential in Sustainable Tourism
Nepal possesses unique conditions for sustainable tourism leadership in South Asia. The country contains exceptional biodiversity. It has a government regulatory framework, however imperfect, that protects national parks and engages communities in conservation. And it has operators like Tiger Tops that have demonstrated sustainable tourism viability over decades.
Yet potential does not equal outcome. The next decade will determine whether Nepal leverages these conditions to position itself as a regional leader in sustainable tourism, or whether it follows the trajectory of other destinations where tourism growth outpaced conservation capacity, resulting in habitat degradation and wildlife decline.
This outcome depends on three factors: greater regulatory coordination between government and private sector operators; industry-wide investment in animal welfare and environmental standards; and consumer preference for genuinely ethical tourism over cheaper alternatives that externalize environmental and animal welfare costs.
Younger entrepreneurs and conservationists in Nepal recognize these imperatives. The question is whether they can coordinate effectively enough to shape the sector's trajectory before growth dynamics become difficult to reverse.
The Next Fifty Years
Tiger Tops enters its second half-century having already redefined what elephant tourism can be. The lodge's ongoing challenge is innovation within constraint — how to continue developing responsible tourism practices, deepening conservation impact, and maintaining animal welfare standards in an environment where regulatory oversight remains inconsistent and competitive pressure from lower-cost operators remains significant.
Jack Edwards, who returned from Singapore financial services to lead the lodge in 2017, embodies the next generation of family stewardship. He carries his father's conservation conviction while operating within a business environment far more complex than Jim Edwards faced in 1971. Balancing these demands — business sustainability, animal welfare, habitat protection, and guest experience — is the ongoing work of ethical tourism.
Nepal's trajectory in sustainable tourism, and Asia's broader evolution toward more ethical animal encounters, will be significantly shaped by whether operators like Tiger Tops can continue to prove that conservation tourism is not a compromise position, but a superior model.
Where to stay
Our member hotels in Nepal
""